Unlimited PTO vs accrued PTO
What is the difference between unlimited PTO and accrued PTO? Accrued PTO builds a balance of days or hours as people work, and that balance can be paid out when they leave. Unlimited PTO has no balance and no cap, so nothing builds up and someone has to make sure people still take time.
Is unlimited PTO or accrued PTO better for a small remote team?
Choose accrued PTO if anyone works in a state that pays out vacation when they leave, such as California, or if you want people to see exactly how many days they have. Choose unlimited PTO with a required minimum if you want no balances to track and you will check that people take their days. Unlimited alone tends to mean less time off: in a March 2026 Patriot Software survey of 1,000 employed Americans, 66% said they would take 15 days or fewer under an unlimited policy (checked November 5, 2026). Neither is right for every team. Not legal advice.
Unlimited PTO vs accrued PTO side by side
| Accrued PTO | Unlimited PTO | Source and date | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paid out when someone leaves | In states that treat earned vacation as wages, yes: California requires all earned and unused vacation paid at the final rate of pay. Elsewhere it depends on your written policy. | Usually no balance to pay. No state page we read says how it treats unlimited plans, so if yours works like accrued time, ask the state first. | California Labor Commissioner, read November 1, 2026; state by state |
| Carryover and use it or lose it | A balance carries over unless your policy caps it. States such as California don't allow earned vacation to be forfeited, though you can cap how much builds up. | Nothing carries over because there is nothing to carry. A required minimum can reset each year. | California Labor Commissioner, read November 1, 2026; state by state |
| Who tracks balances | Someone, every pay period: accrual rate, hours used, hours left. | No balances. You still keep one shared record of who is away and who covers. | Ample's guides, accrual calculator and unlimited PTO tracker |
| Risk of taking less time | Lower: a visible balance reminds people to use it. | Higher without a minimum: 66% said they would take 15 days or fewer a year, and 91% said unlimited PTO should include a mandatory minimum. | Patriot Software survey, 1,000 employed US adults, March 2026; checked November 5, 2026 |
| Federal rule | The federal Fair Labor Standards Act doesn't require pay for time not worked, such as vacations. The US Department of Labor calls these benefits matters of agreement between employer and employee. | US Department of Labor, checked November 5, 2026 | |
When each one fits a small remote team
- Accrued fits when someone works in a state that pays out vacation, you want a stated number people can plan around, or you run payroll that already tracks balances.
- Unlimited fits when you would rather not carry balances, you can review who has taken time, and you are willing to set a minimum. The unlimited PTO policy template has a filled example with a 15-day minimum.
- Either way, people in different states can fall under different rules, so check the state where each person works, not where the company is based.
Switching from accrued to unlimited
Decide what happens to existing balances before the change: pay them out, honor them as a minimum, or keep them until used. In states that treat earned vacation as wages, balances people have already earned can't just be dropped: see which states require PTO payout. Get local advice before you switch. This is not legal advice.
Tools for each
For accrued time, the PTO accrual calculator works out how a balance builds, and the PTO policy template sets a fixed allowance, carryover and payout. For unlimited time, the unlimited PTO tracker guide shows how to run it without balances. Ample is ours: it is built for unlimited PTO teams, shows leave dates, coverage and handoffs, and does not calculate accruals or carryover. It is free while in beta.