What do you do when two employees ask for the same days off?
What do you do when two employees ask for the same days off? Use one rule you can say out loud, usually first request approved first, apply it to both people, and offer the second person the nearest open dates.
How do you decide who gets the time off?
Count the minimum people you need first; if that many are still working, approve both. If not, use the rule in your policy: first request wins, or alternate the busy weeks each year. Reply to both on the same day, tell the second person the dates that are free, and write the rule down so the same thing doesn't come up next year.
Step 1: count before you choose
Many clashes aren't clashes. Open the team coverage planner for the dates and check whether the minimum is still met with both out, or with a handoff to someone else. Only if it isn't do you need a rule.
Step 2: pick one rule
| Rule | Works when | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| First request approved first | Dates are in writing with a timestamp, as in the request time off form | People who ask a year ahead for every peak week. Add a limit, such as one peak week each. |
| Take turns by year | The same weeks clash every year, like the winter holidays | Keep a short list of who had which week last year. |
| Split the dates | Both can accept half the time | Ask both before you offer it. |
I'd use first request first for most teams, plus a turn rotation for the one or two holiday weeks everyone wants. Whichever you choose, put it in the PTO policy.
Step 3: reply to both the same day
To the person who asked second (first come, first served)
Hi [Name], [Teammate] asked for [dates] on [day] and I approved it, so I can't also approve yours: we need at least [minimum] people working. I'd rather tell you now than later. [Other dates] are open and I'll approve them the day you send them. If you can only go on [dates], tell me and I'll see whether [teammate] could shift. [Your name]
To both people (you want to give each some of it)
Hi [Name] and [Name], You both asked for [dates] and I can only approve one of you. Here's what I can do: [Name] takes [first half] and [Name] takes [second half], or one of you takes [dates] and the other gets first pick of [next peak period]. Reply to me by [day] with which you'd prefer and I'll confirm. [Your name]
Replace the bracketed parts. Free to copy, no signup. Not legal advice; if a request is for protected leave such as FMLA leave, don't use a first-come rule on it; check with HR.
Keep it fair
- Don't decide on whose reason sounds better.
- Don't approve one person verbally and answer the other in writing; send both replies together.
- Write the rule on the team vacation calendar page or the policy, so nobody learns it from a refusal.
For the full set of ways to say no, see how to deny a time off request; for December, the holiday coverage schedule template rotates the big weeks.